| Year | All-Star (Pos.) |
|---|---|
| 2025 | *Junior Caminero (3B) Jonathan Aranda (1B) Brandon Lowe (2B) |
| 2024 | Isaac Paredes (3B) |
| 2023 | *Randy Arozarena (OF) *Yandy Díaz (1B) Wander Franco (SS) Shane McClanahan (LHP) |
| 2022 | *Shane McClanahan (LHP) |
| 2021 | Andrew Kittredge (RHP) Joey Wendle (SS) Mike Zunino (C) |
| 2019 | Brandon Lowe (2B) Austin Meadows (OF) Charlie Morton (RHP) |
| 2018 | ºWilson Ramos (C) Blake Snell (LHP) |
| 2017 | *Corey Dickerson (DH) Chris Archer (RHP) |
| 2016 | Alex Colome (RHP) |
| 2015 | Chris Archer (RHP) Brad Boxberger (RHP) |
| 2014 | David Price (LHP) |
| 2013 | Matt Moore (RHP) Ben Zobrist (INF/OF) |
| 2012 | David Price (LHP) Fernando Rodney (RHP) |
| 2011 | Matt Joyce (OF) David Price (LHP) James Shields (RHP) |
| 2010 | *Carl Crawford (LF) *Evan Longoria (3B) *David Price (LHP) Rafael Soriano (RHP) |
| 2009 | Jason Bartlett (SS) Carl Crawford (LF) ºEvan Longoria (3B) Carlos Peña (1B) Ben Zobrist (INF/OF) |
| 2008 | Scott Kazmir (LHP) Evan Longoria (3B) Dioner Navarro (C) |
| 2007 | Carl Crawford (OF) |
| 2006 | Scott Kazmir (LHP) |
| 2005 | Danys Baez (RHP) |
| 2004 | Carl Crawford (OF) |
| 2003 | Lance Carter (RHP) |
| 2002 | Randy Winn (OF) |
| 2001 | Greg Vaughn (OF) |
| 2000 | Fred McGriff (1B) |
| 1999 | ºJose Canseco (OF) Roberto Hernandez (P) |
| 1998 | Rolando Arrojo (P) |
| *Started game | |
| ºVoted as starter but did not play due to injury |