| 2023 |
Nolan Arenado, 3B |
| 2022 |
Paul Goldschmidt, 1B; Nolan Arenado, 3B; Albert Pujols, DH; Ryan Helsley, P; Miles Mikolas, P |
| 2021 |
Nolan Arenado, 3B; Yadier Molina, C; Alex Reyes, P |
| 2020 |
No game due to COVID-19 pandemic |
| 2019 |
Paul DeJong, SS |
| 2018 |
Yadier Molina, C; Miles Mikolas, P |
| 2017 |
Yadier Molina, C; Carlos Martinez, P |
| 2016 |
Matt Carpenter, 3B; Aledmys Diaz, SS |
| 2015 |
Matt Holliday, OF; Yadier Molina, C; Jhonny Peralta, SS; Carlos Martinez, P; Michael Wacha, P; Trevor Rosenthal, P |
| 2014 |
Matt Carpenter, 3B; Yadier Molina, C; Pat Neshek, P; Adam Wainwright, P; Mike Matheny, Manager; Mike Aldrete, Coach; Blaise Ilsley, Coach; Derek Lilliquist, Coach; John Mabry, Coach; Chris Maloney, Coach; Jose Oquendo, Coach |
| 2013 |
Carlos Beltran, OF; Matt Carpenter, 2B; Allen Craig, 1B; Yadier Molina, C; Edward Mujica, P; Adam Wainwright, P |
| 2012 |
Carlos Beltran, OF; David Freese, 3B; Rafael Furcal, SS; Matt Holliday, OF; Lance Lynn, P; Yadier Molina, C; Tony La Russa, Manager; Dave Duncan, Coach; Derek Lilliquist, Coach; Mark McGwire, Coach; Dave McKay, Coach; Jose Oquendo, Coach; Joe Pettini, Coach |
| 2011 |
Lance Berkman, OF; Matt Holliday, OF; Yadier Molina, C |
| 2010 |
Chris Carpenter, P; Matt Holliday, OF; Yadier Molina, C; Albert Pujols, 1B; Adam Wainwright, P |
| 2009 |
Ryan Franklin, P; Yadier Molina, C; Albert Pujols, 1B |
| 2008 |
Ryan Ludwick, OF; Albert Pujols, 1B |
| 2007 |
Albert Pujols, 1B |
| 2006 |
Chris Carpenter, P; David Eckstein, SS; Albert Pujols, 1B; Scott Rolen, 3B |
| 2005 |
Chris Carpenter, P; David Eckstein, SS; Jim Edmonds, CF; Jason Isringhausen, P; Albert Pujols, 1B; Scott Rolen, 3B; Tony La Russa, Manager; Dave Duncan, Coach; Marty Mason, Coach; Jose Oquendo, Coach; Joe Pettini, Coach; Barry Weinberg, Trainer |
| 2004 |
Albert Pujols, 1B; Edgar Renteria, SS; Scott Rolen, 3B |
| 2003 |
Jim Edmonds, OF; Albert Pujols, OF; Edgar Renteria, SS; Scott Rolen, 3B; Woody Williams, P; Tony La Russa, Manager |
| 2002 |
Matt Morris, P |
| 2001 |
Matt Morris, P; Albert Pujols, 3B |
| 2000 |
Jim Edmonds, OF; Mark McGwire, 1B; Darryl Kile, P; Edgar Renteria, SS |
| 1999 |
Kent Bottenfield, P; Mark McGwire, 1B |
| 1998 |
Mark McGwire, 1B |
| 1997 |
Ray Lankford, OF; Royce Clayton, SS |
| 1996 |
Ozzie Smith, SS |
| 1995 |
Tom Henke, P; Ozzie Smith, SS |
| 1994 |
Gregg Jeffries, 1B; Ozzie Smith, SS |
| 1993 |
Gregg Jeffries, 1B; Lee Smith, P |
| 1992 |
Tom Pagnozzi, C; Lee Smith, P; Ozzie Smith, SS; Bob Tewksbury, P; Joe Torre, Coach |
| 1991 |
Felix Jose, OF, Lee Smith, P; Ozzie Smith, SS |
| 1990 |
Ozzie Smith, SS |
| 1989 |
Vince Coleman, OF; Pedro Guerrero, DH; Tony Pena, C; Ozzie Smith, SS |
| 1988 |
Vince Coleman, OF; Willie McGee, OF; Ozzie Smith, SS; Todd Worrell, P; Whitey Herzog, Manager; Rich Hacker, Coach; Nick Leyva, Coach; Johny Lewis, Coach |
| 1987 |
Jack Clark, 1B; Willie McGee, OF; Ozzie Smith, SS |
| 1986 |
Ozzie Smith, SS; Whitey Herzog, Manager; Mike Roarke, Coach |
| 1985 |
Joaquin Andujar, P; Jack Clark, 1B; Tom Herr, 2B; Willie McGee, OF; Ozzie Smith, SS |
| 1984 |
Joaquin Andujar, P; Ozzie Smith, SS; Bruce Sutter, P |
| 1983 |
Ozzie Smith, SS; Willie McGee, OF; George Hendrick, OF; Whitey Herzog, Manager; Chuck Hiller, Coach; Dave Ricketts, Coach |
| 1982 |
Ozzie Smith, SS; Lonnie Smith, OF |
| 1981 |
Bruce Sutter, P |
| 1980 |
George Hendrick, OF; Keith Hernandez, 1B; Ken Reitz, 3B |
| 1979 |
Lou Brock, OF; Keith Hernandez, 1B; Ted Simmons, C; Gary Templeton, SS; Dave Ricketts, Coach |
| 1978 |
Ted Simmons, C |
| 1977 |
Ted Simmons, C; Gary Templeton, SS |
| 1976 |
Bake McBride, OF |
| 1975 |
Lou Brock, OF; Reggie Smith, OF; Red Schoendienst, Coach |
| 1974 |
Ted Simmons, C; Lou Brock, OF; Reggie Smith, OF; Lynn McGlothen, P; Red Schoendienst, Coach |
| 1973 |
Rick Wise, P; Joe Torre, 3B; Ted Simmons, C |
| 1972 |
Bob Gibson, P; Lou Brock, OF; Joe Torre, 3B; Ted Simmons, C; Red Schoendienst, Coach |
| 1971 |
Joe Torre, 3B; Steve Carlton, P; Lou Brock, OF |
| 1970 |
Rich Allen, 1B; Bob Gibson, P; Joe Torre, C |
| 1969 |
Red Schoendienst, Manager; Steve Carlton, P; Bob Gibson, P |
| 1968 |
Red Schoendienst, Manager; Steve Carlton, P, Curt FLood, OF; Bob Gibson, P; Julian Javier, 2B |
| 1967 |
Lou Brock, OF; Orlando Cepeda, 1B; Bob Gibson, P; Tim McCarver, C |
| 1966 |
Curt Flood, OF; Bob Gibson, P; Tim McCarver, C |
| 1965 |
Bob Gibson, P |
| 1964 |
Ken Boyer, 3B; Curt Flood, OF; Dick Groat, SS; Bill White, 1B |
| 1963 |
Ken Boyer, 3B; Dick Groat, SS; Julian Javier, 2B; Stan Musial, OF; Bill White, 1B |
| 1962 |
Ken Boyer, 3B; Bob Gibson, P; Stan Musial, OF |
| 1961 |
Ken Boyer, 3B; Stan Musial, OF; Bill White, 1B |
| 1960 |
Ken Boyer, 3B; Larry Jackson, P; Lindy McDaniel, P; Stan Musial, OF; Bill White, 1B |
| 1959 |
Ken Boyer, 3B; Joe Cunningham, OF; Wilmer Mizell, P; Stan Musial, 1B; Hal Smith, C; Bill White, OF |
| 1958 |
Don Blasingame, 2B; Larry Jackson, P; Stan Musial, 1B |
| 1957 |
Larry Jackson, P; Wally Moon, OF; Stan Musial, 1B; Hal Smith, C |
| 1956 |
Ken Boyer, 3B; Stan Musial, OF; Rip Repulski, OF |
| 1955 |
Luis Arroyo, P; Harvey Haddix, P; Stan Musial, 1B; Red Schoendienst, 2B |
| 1954 |
Harvey Haddix, P; Ray Jablonski, 3B; Stan Musial, OF; Red Schoendienst, 2B |
| 1953 |
Harvey Haddix, P; Stan Musial, OF; Del Rice, C; Red Schoendienst, 2B; Enos Slaughter, OF |
| 1952 |
Stan Musial, OF; Red Schoendienst, 2B; Enos Slaughter, OF; Gerry Staley, P |
| 1951 |
Stan Musial, OF; Red Schoendiesnt, 2B; Enos Slaughter, OF; Wally Westlake, OF |
| 1950 |
Marty Marion, SS; Stan Musial, 1B; Red Schoendienst, 2B; Enos Slaughter, OF |
| 1949 |
Eddie Kazak, 3B; Marty Marion, SS; Red Munger, P; Stan Musial, OF; Howie Pollet, P; Red Schoendienst, 2B; Enos Slaughter, OF |
| 1948 |
Harry Breechen, P; Marty Marion, SS; Stan Musial, OF; Red Schoendienst, 2B; Enos Slaughter, OF |
| 1947 |
Eddie Dyer, Manager; Harry Brecheen, P; Whitey Kurowski, 3B; Marty Marion, SS; Red Munger, P; Stan Musial, 1B; Enos Slaughter, OF |
| 1946 |
Whitey Kurowski, 3B; Marty Marion, SS; Stan Musial, OF; Howie Pollet, P; Red Schoendienst, 2B; Enos Slaughter, OF |
| 1945 |
No game due to World War II travel restrictions |
| 1944 |
Billy Southworth, Manager; Walker Cooper, C; Whitey Kurowski, 3B; Max Lanier, P; Marty Marion, SS; Red Munger, P; Stan Musial, OF |
| 1943 |
Billy Southworth, Manager; Mort Cooper, P; Walker Cooper, C; Whitey Kurowski, 3B; Max Lanier, P; Marty Marion, SS; Stan Musial, OF; Howie Pollet, P; Harry Walker, OF |
| 1942 |
Jim Brown, 2B; Mort Cooper, P; Walker Cooper, C; Terry Moore, OF; Enos Slaughter, OF |
| 1941 |
Johnny Mize, 1B; Terry Moore, OF; Enos Slaughter, OF; Lon Warneke, P |
| 1940 |
Johnny Mize, 1B; Terry Moore, OF |
| 1939 |
Curt Davis, P; Joe Medwick, OF; Johnny Mize, 1B; Terry Moore, OF; Lon Warneke, P |
| 1938 |
Joe Medwick, OF |
| 1937 |
Dizzy Dean, P; Pepper Martin, OF; Joe Medwick, OF; Johnny Mize, 1B |
| 1936 |
Rip Collins, 1B; Dizzy Dean, P; Leo Durocher, SS; Stu Martin, 2B; Joe Medwick, OF |
| 1935 |
Frank Frisch, Manager and 2B; Rip Collins, 1B; Dizzy Dean, P; Pepper Martin, 3B; Joe Medwick, OF; Bill Walker, P; Burgess Whitehead, 2B |
| 1934 |
Dizzy Dean, P; Frank Frisch, 2B; Pepper Martin, 3B; Joe Medwick, OF |
| 1933 |
Frank Frisch, 2B; Bill Hallahan, P; Pepper Martin, 3B; Jim Wilson, C |
