- 2023: Félix Bautista (RHP), Yennier Cano (RHP), Austin Hays (OF), Adley Rutschman (C)
- 2022: Jorge López (RHP)
- 2021: Cedric Mullins (OF)
- 2019: John Means (LHP)
- 2018: Manny Machado (SS)
- 2017: Jonathan Schoop (2B)
- 2016: Brad Brach (RHP), Zach Britton (LHP), Manny Machado (3B), Mark Trumbo (OF), Matt Wieters (C)
- 2015: Zach Britton (LHP), Adam Jones (OF), Manny Machado (3B), Darren O'Day (RHP)
- 2014: Nelson Cruz (DH), Adam Jones (OF), Matt Wieters (C)
- 2013: Chris Davis (1B), J.J. Hardy (SS), Adam Jones (OF), Manny Machado (3B), Chris Tillman (RHP)
- 2012: Jim Johnson (P), Adam Jones (OF), Matt Wieters (C)
- 2011: Matt Wieters (C)
- 2010: Ty Wiggington (1B)
- 2009: Adam Jones (OF)
- 2008: George Sherrill (LHP)
- 2007: Brian Roberts (2B)
- 2006: Miguel Tejada (SS)
- 2005: Brian Roberts (2B), Miguel Tejada (SS), Melvin Mora (3B), B.J. Ryan (P)
- 2004: Miguel Tejada (SS)
- 2003: Melvin Mora (OF)
- 2002: Tony Batista (3B)
- 2001: Cal Ripken (SS-3B)
- 2000: Cal Ripken (SS-3B), Mike Bordick (SS)
- 1999: Harold Baines (OF), Mike Mussina (RHP), Cal Ripken (SS-3B), B.J. Surhoff (OF)
- 1998: Roberto Alomar (2B), Rafael Palmeiro (OF), Cal Ripken (SS-3B)
- 1997: Roberto Alomar (2B), Brady Anderson (OF), Jimmy Key (LHP), Mike Mussina (RHP), Cal Ripken (SS-2B)
- 1996: Roberto Alomar (2B), Brady Anderson (OF), Cal Ripken (SS-3B)
- 1995: Cal Ripken (SS-3B)
- 1994: Mike Mussina (RHP), Cal Ripken (SS-3B), Lee Smith (RHP)
- 1993: Mike Mussina (RHP), Cal Ripken (SS-3B)
- 1992: Brady Anderson (OF), Mike Mussina (RHP), Cal Ripken (SS-3B)
- 1991: Cal Ripken (SS-3B)
- 1990: Gregg Olson (RHP), Cal Ripken (SS-3B)
- 1989: Mickey Tettleton (C), Cal Ripken (SS-3B)
- 1988: Cal Ripken (SS-3B)
- 1987: Terry Kennedy (C), Cal Ripken (SS-3B)
- 1986: Don Aase (RHP), Eddie Murray (1B), Cal Ripken (SS-3B)
- 1985: Eddie Murray (1B), Cal Ripken (SS-3B)
- 1984: Mike Boddicker (RHP), Eddie Murray (1B), Cal Ripken (SS-3B)
- 1983: Tippy Martinez (LHP), Eddie Murray (1B), Cal Ripken (SS-3B)
- 1982: Eddie Murray (1B)
- 1981: Scott McGregor (LHP), Eddie Murray (1B), Ken Singleton (OF)
- 1980: Al Bumbry (OF), Steve Stone (RHP)
- 1979: Ken Singleton (OF), Don Stanhouse (RHP)
- 1978: Jim Palmer (RHP), Mike Flanagan (LHP), Eddie Murray (1B)
- 1977: Jim Palmer (RHP), Ken Singleton (OF)
- 1976: Mark Belanger (SS), Bobby Grich (SS-2B)
- 1975: Jim Palmer (RHP)
- 1974: Mike Cuellar (LHP), Bobby Grich (SS-2B), Brooks Robinson (3B)
- 1973: Paul Blair (OF), Brooks Robinson (3B)
- 1972: Pat Dobson (RHP), Bobby Grich (SS-2B), Dave McNally (LHP), Frank Robinson (OF), Jim Palmer (RHP), Brooks Robinson (3B)
- 1971: Don Buford (OF), Mike Cuellar (LHP), Jim Palmer (RHP), Boog Powell (1B), Brooks Robinson (3B), Frank Robinson (OF)
- 1970: Mike Cuellar (LHP), Dave Johnson (2B), Dave McNally (LHP), Jim Palmer (RHP), Boog Powell (1B), Brook Robinson (3B), Frank Robinson (OF)
- 1969: Paul Blair (OF), Dave Johnson (2B), Dave McNally (LHP), Boog Powell (1B), Brooks Robinson (3B), Frank Robinson (OF)
- 1968: Dave Johnson (2B), Boog Powell (1B), Brooks Robinson (3B)
- 1967: Andy Etchebarren (C), Brooks Robinson (3B), Frank Robinson (OF)
- 1966: Steve Barber (OF), Andy Etchebarren (C), Brooks Robinson (3B), Frank Robinson (OF)
- 1965: Milt Pappas (RHP), Brooks Robinson (3B)
- 1964: Luis Aparicio (LHP), Brooks Robinson (3B), Norm Siebern (RHP)
- 1963: Luis Aparicio (RHP), Brooks Robinson (3B), Steve Barber (LHP)
- 1962: Jim Gentile (1B), Milt Pappas (RHP), Brooks Robinson (3B), Hoyt Wilhelm (RHP)
- 1961: Jack Brandt (OF), Jim Gentile (1B), Brooks Robinson (3B), Hoyt Wilhelm (RHP)
- 1960: Chuck Estrada (RHP), Jim Gentile (1B)
- 1959: Billy O'Dell (LHP), Gus Triandos (C), Jerry Walker (RHP), Hoyt Wilhelm (RHP), Gene Woodling (OF)
- 1958: Billy O'Dell (LHP), Gus Triandos (C)
- 1957: George Kell (3B), Billy Loes (RHP), Gus Triandos (C)
- 1956: George Kell (3B)
- 1955: Jim Wilson (RHP)
- 1954: Bob Turley (RHP)